BMW i4 vs i5: Comprehensive Comparison
Overview of BMW i4 vs i5
The BMW i4 and i5 are two cutting-edge electric vehicles (EVs) from BMW, each catering to different needs and preferences. The BMW i4 is a compact executive car that combines performance with practicality, while the BMW i5 is a mid-size luxury sedan offering more space and enhanced features. Let’s dive into the specifics of each model to understand their differences and help you decide which one suits you best.
Introduction to BMW i4
Design and Build
The BMW i4 boasts a sleek and modern design, reflecting BMW’s commitment to combining aesthetics with aerodynamics. The exterior features sharp lines, a distinctive kidney grille, and stylish LED headlights. The interior is equally impressive, offering a driver-focused cockpit with high-quality materials, a digital instrument cluster, and a large infotainment screen.
Performance Specs
The i4 comes in two main variants: the eDrive40 and the M50. The eDrive40 features a rear-wheel-drive setup with a single electric motor producing 335 horsepower, enabling a 0-60 mph time of around 5.5 seconds. The M50, on the other hand, offers an all-wheel-drive configuration with dual electric motors, delivering up to 536 horsepower and achieving 0-60 mph in just 3.7 seconds.
Pricing and Models
The base price for the BMW i4 eDrive40 starts at approximately $55,400, while the M50 variant starts at $66,900. These prices reflect the standard features, with various packages and options available to customize the vehicle to your liking.
Introduction to BMW i5
Design and Build
The BMW i5, as a larger sibling to the i4, offers a more spacious and luxurious design. Its exterior is characterized by elegant lines, a larger kidney grille, and sophisticated lighting elements. Inside, the i5 provides an upscale environment with premium materials, advanced technology, and ample room for passengers and cargo.
Performance Specs
The i5 is available in two primary versions: the eDrive40 and the M60. The eDrive40 comes with a rear-wheel-drive system and a single electric motor generating 335 horsepower. The M60 variant, featuring an all-wheel-drive setup, boasts dual electric motors producing up to 590 horsepower, allowing it to sprint from 0-60 mph in just 3.8 seconds.
Pricing and Models
Starting prices for the BMW i5 begin at around $66,800 for the eDrive40 model and can go up to $84,100 for the M60 variant. Like the i4, the i5 offers a range of customization options, ensuring a personalized driving experience.
Detailed Feature Comparison
Dimensions and Weight
BMW i4 Dimensions
- Length: 188.5 inches
- Width: 81.6 inches
- Height: 57.0 inches
- Wheelbase: 112.4 inches
- Curb Weight: 4665 lbs
BMW i5 Dimensions
- Length: 199.2 inches
- Width: 84.9 inches
- Height: 59.6 inches
- Wheelbase: 117.9 inches
- Curb Weight: 4916 lbs
The BMW i5 is notably larger than the i4, offering more space for passengers and cargo. This difference in size can be a deciding factor for buyers prioritizing interior space and comfort.
Interior and Cargo Space
BMW i4 Interior
The i4’s interior is designed for both comfort and functionality. It features comfortable seating for up to five passengers, a large digital dashboard, and a user-friendly infotainment system. The cargo space in the i4 stands at 16.6 cubic feet, which is ample for a compact car.
BMW i5 Interior
The i5 offers a more luxurious interior with additional space, making it suitable for families or those who prefer more room. It includes advanced technology such as a larger infotainment screen, premium audio systems, and enhanced driver assistance features. The cargo capacity of the i5 is slightly larger at 17.3 cubic feet, providing more flexibility for storage.
Performance and Efficiency
Powertrain and Driving Range
BMW i4 Powertrain Options
- eDrive40: Single electric motor, rear-wheel drive, 335 hp, 0-60 mph in 5.5 seconds.
- M50: Dual electric motors, all-wheel drive, 536 hp, 0-60 mph in 3.7 seconds.
The i4 offers a battery capacity of 83.9 kWh, providing an estimated range of up to 300 miles on a single charge for the eDrive40, while the M50 achieves around 245 miles.
BMW i5 Powertrain Options
- eDrive40: Single electric motor, rear-wheel drive, 335 hp, 0-60 mph in 5.7 seconds.
- M60: Dual electric motors, all-wheel drive, 590 hp, 0-60 mph in 3.8 seconds.
The i5 features a larger battery pack with a capacity of 101.7 kWh, delivering a range of up to 315 miles for the eDrive40 and around 290 miles for the M60.
Handling and Driving Experience
BMW i4 Handling
The BMW i4 is known for its agile handling and responsive steering. It comes with adaptive suspension options that enhance the ride quality, making it suitable for both city driving and long-distance travel. The various driving modes, including Eco Pro and Sport, allow drivers to customize their driving experience.
BMW i5 Handling
The i5, being a larger vehicle, offers a more composed and stable ride. It features an advanced air suspension system that ensures a smooth and comfortable journey, even on rough terrains. The i5 also includes various driving modes and adaptive features that enhance its overall performance.
Technology and Safety Features
Infotainment and Connectivity
BMW i4 Infotainment System
The i4 comes equipped with BMW’s latest iDrive 8 infotainment system, featuring a 14.9-inch touchscreen and a 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster. It supports wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, allowing seamless smartphone integration. Additional features include a Harman Kardon sound system, wireless charging, and multiple USB ports.
BMW i5 Infotainment System
The i5 takes technology a step further with its advanced infotainment setup. It also features the iDrive 8 system with larger screens and enhanced functionality. The i5 includes a Bowers & Wilkins Diamond Surround Sound System for superior audio quality and a range of connectivity options to keep passengers entertained and connected.
Advanced Driver Assistance Systems
BMW i4 Safety Features
The i4 is equipped with a comprehensive suite of safety features, including:
- Standard blind-spot monitoring
- Lane departure warning
- Forward collision warning with automatic emergency braking
- Optional adaptive cruise control with stop-and-go capability
BMW i5 Safety Features
The i5 offers similar safety features but with additional enhancements, such as:
- Standard rear cross-traffic alert
- Standard front and rear parking sensors
- Optional autonomous driving features for added convenience and safety
- Advanced driver assistance systems like active lane keeping and traffic jam assist
Ownership and Maintenance
Warranty and Service Plans
BMW i4 Warranty Details
- Basic Warranty: 4 years/50,000 miles
- Drivetrain Warranty: 4 years/50,000 miles
- Rust Warranty: 12 years/unlimited miles
- Roadside Assistance: 4 years/unlimited miles
- Hybrid-EV Warranty: 8 years/100,000 miles
- Free Maintenance: 3 years/36,000 miles
BMW i5 Warranty Details
- Basic Warranty: 4 years/50,000 miles
- Drivetrain Warranty: 4 years/50,000 miles
- Rust Warranty: 12 years/unlimited miles
- Roadside Assistance: 4 years/unlimited miles
- Hybrid-EV Warranty: 8 years/100,000 miles
- Free Maintenance: 3 years/36,000 miles
Cost of Ownership
BMW i4 Running Costs
The i4 offers competitive running costs for an electric vehicle. Maintenance is relatively low due to fewer moving parts compared to traditional combustion engines. Insurance rates are moderate, and buyers can benefit from federal and state incentives for electric vehicles, reducing the overall cost of ownership.
BMW i5 Running Costs
The i5, being a larger and more luxurious vehicle, may incur slightly higher running costs. However, the maintenance remains manageable, and similar incentives apply. The i5’s higher initial cost is offset by its enhanced features and greater range.
Pros and Cons
Advantages of BMW i4
Performance and Efficiency
The i4 offers impressive acceleration, especially in the M50 variant, making it a thrilling car to drive. Its range is suitable for daily commutes and longer trips.
Technology and Comfort
The i4 is packed with the latest technology, ensuring a comfortable and connected driving experience. The interior is well-designed, offering both comfort and functionality.
Cost and Value
The i4 provides excellent value for money, especially for those looking for a balance of performance, technology, and price.
Advantages of BMW i5
Performance and Efficiency
The i5 stands out with its powerful performance, particularly in the M60 variant. It also offers a slightly longer range, making it ideal for those who travel longer distances frequently.
Technology and Comfort
The i5’s interior is more spacious and luxurious, providing a superior level of comfort. Passengers can enjoy a quieter cabin with high-end materials and additional legroom and headroom compared to the i4. The i5 also includes more advanced climate control options and additional rear-seat amenities, making it an excellent choice for those who prioritize comfort on longer journeys.
Drawbacks of Both Models
BMW i4 Drawbacks
Despite its many strengths, the BMW i4 has some limitations. The rear-seat space is somewhat limited compared to other models in its class, which might be a concern for those who often carry passengers. Additionally, the base model lacks some advanced features found in the i5, and the optional packages can quickly add to the cost.
BMW i5 Drawbacks
The BMW i5, while luxurious, comes at a higher price point, which might be prohibitive for some buyers. Its larger size can also make it less agile in city driving compared to the i4. Furthermore, the additional features and technology can result in higher maintenance costs over time.
Additional Sections for an In-Depth Comparison
Charging and Infrastructure
BMW i4 Charging Options
The BMW i4 supports both AC and DC fast charging. With a standard 240-volt Level 2 charger, the i4 can achieve a full charge in approximately 8 hours. For quicker charging, the i4 is compatible with DC fast chargers, which can provide an 80% charge in about 35 minutes.
BMW i5 Charging Options
Similarly, the BMW i5 supports both AC and DC fast charging. Due to its larger battery, a full charge with a Level 2 charger takes around 10 hours. Using a DC fast charger, the i5 can reach 80% charge in approximately 40 minutes, making it suitable for long-distance travel with fewer stops.
Environmental Impact
BMW i4 Environmental Benefits
The BMW i4’s electric drivetrain significantly reduces greenhouse gas emissions compared to traditional combustion engines. The vehicle’s production process also incorporates sustainable practices, such as using recycled materials and renewable energy sources.
BMW i5 Environmental Benefits
The i5 offers similar environmental advantages, with an emphasis on sustainability. Its larger battery capacity contributes to a longer range, which can reduce the need for frequent charging stops and further minimize environmental impact over time.
Resale Value and Market Trends
BMW i4 Resale Value
Electric vehicles like the BMW i4 tend to retain their value well due to growing demand for sustainable transportation options. The i4’s advanced technology and performance capabilities make it an attractive option on the used car market.
BMW i5 Resale Value
The i5, being a more luxurious and advanced model, also maintains strong resale value. Its larger size and enhanced features appeal to a broad range of buyers, ensuring continued demand in the used car market.
User Reviews and Experiences
BMW i4 User Reviews
Owners of the BMW i4 praise its dynamic performance, sleek design, and cutting-edge technology. Many appreciate its balance of sportiness and practicality, making it a popular choice for daily commuting and weekend getaways.
BMW i5 User Reviews
The BMW i5 receives high marks for its comfort, spacious interior, and advanced features. Users often highlight its smooth ride, quiet cabin, and impressive acceleration as key benefits, making it a preferred option for long-distance travel and family use.
The Bottom Lines
When comparing the BMW i4 vs i5, it’s clear that both models offer exceptional features and performance tailored to different needs. The BMW i4 is ideal for those seeking a sporty and efficient vehicle with a focus on agility and affordability. Its compact size and impressive range make it perfect for city driving and daily commutes.
On the other hand, the BMW i5 is designed for those who prioritize luxury, space, and advanced technology. Its larger size and enhanced comfort features provide a superior driving experience, especially for long journeys and family trips.
Ultimately, the choice between the BMW i4 and i5 depends on your specific preferences and requirements. Both models embody BMW’s commitment to innovation, sustainability, and driving pleasure, ensuring you can’t go wrong with either option. Whether you opt for the dynamic i4 or the luxurious i5, you’ll enjoy the cutting-edge technology and premium quality that BMW is known for.
